Skip to content

Reciprocating Saw vs. Jigsaw: Which One Do You Actually Need for Your Project?

In the world of American DIY and home renovation, choosing the right tool is the difference between a successful "Demo Day" and a ruined project. Two of the most common tools found in a Makita-compatible tool shed are the Jigsaw and the Reciprocating Saw. While both use a back-and-forth motion, they serve entirely different purposes.

Are you looking for surgical precision or raw demolition power? Let’s dive into the technical specs of the WOODSTARTER brushless lineup to find your perfect match.

Reciprocating Saw vs. Jigsaw: Which One Do You Actually Need for Your Project?

1. The Jigsaw: The Master of Precision and Curves

The WOODSTARTER Brushless Cordless Jigsaw is designed for "The Creator." If your project involves intricate shapes, furniture building, or clean interior cutouts, this is your primary tool.

Key Features for DIYers:

  • 2900 SPM Variable Speed: Three adjustable settings (1000/2000/2900 SPM) allow you to tailor the speed to wood, aluminum, or steel.
  • 4-Level Orbital Settings: Adjust the "aggressiveness" of the cut. Lower settings for clean, slow cuts; higher settings for fast, rough cuts.
  • Built-in Dust-Blowing & Vacuum Integration: Unlike cheap models, this jigsaw keeps your cut line visible by clearing sawdust instantly.
  • 45° to 90° Bevel Cutting: Perfect for angled joins and decorative edges.

Best For: Crafting, cabinetry, and any task where the "finish" matters.


2. The Reciprocating Saw: The King of Demolition

Commonly known as a "Sawzall" in the US, the WOODSTARTER Cordless Reciprocating Saw is built for "The Destroyer." This is the tool you grab when things need to come down fast.

Why the WOODSTARTER Recipro Saw Stands Out:

  • High-Power 3500 SPM: With a 1-inch stroke length, this saw delivers significantly more speed than standard DIY models, making short work of 2x4s and PVC.
  • Brushless Efficiency: The motor stays cooler and runs longer, which is essential for heavy-duty demolition.
  • Tool-Free Blade Change: Switch between the included wood and metal blades in seconds without hunting for an Allen wrench.
  • Dual Cooling System: Specifically engineered to prevent overheating during long sessions of cutting pallets or tree branches.

Best For: Tearing down decks, pruning trees, plumbing repairs, and cutting through wood with embedded nails.


3. Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature WOODSTARTER Jigsaw WOODSTARTER Reciprocating Saw
Top Speed 2900 SPM 3500 SPM
Primary Strength Precision & Curves Power & Speed
Special Function 4-Level Orbital Action Tool-Free Blade Change
Battery Support Makita 18V Compatible Makita 18V Compatible
Work Light Integrated LED Integrated LED

4. Solving Your Project Pain Points

"Why is my blade breaking?"

Usually, this is a TPI (Teeth Per Inch) issue. For the reciprocating saw, use a lower TPI (6-10) for thick wood and a higher TPI (14-24) for metal pipes. Both WOODSTARTER kits come with multiple blades to ensure you have the right tooth count for the job.

"How do I prevent vibration?"

With the jigsaw, ensure your orbital setting matches the thickness of the wood. With the recipro saw, always keep the "shoe" pressed firmly against the material. Our anti-slip grips are ergonomically designed to absorb this shock, reducing hand fatigue during long DIY sessions.


Conclusion: Which One Should You Buy?

If you are a home renovator or an active gardener, the high-torque power of the Cordless Reciprocating Saw is an absolute necessity for demolition and pruning.

However, if you are a hobbyist or DIY crafter looking to build shelves or custom decor, the Brushless Cordless Jigsaw offers the control and cleanliness you need.

Pro Tip: Since both tools are compatible with Makita-style batteries, many of our customers buy both to complete their "Ultimate Demo & Create" kit!